https://www.pri.org/stories/2019-10-31/how-father-american-egyptology-underestimated-what-some-call-real-life-wakanda
How 'the father of American Egyptology' underestimated what some call the real-life Wakanda
Today, that full collection is being exhibited for the first time as part of a trend among museums to reexamine past archeologists' conclusions and the biases that affected their work. The Ancient Nubia Now exhibit at the Museum of Fine Arts in Boston discusses some of what Reisner, one of their own archaeologists and curators, got wrong in his representation of history.
Kerma: Beads and pendants: faience, amethyst, glazed crystal, carnelian, shell, garnet, granite, August 10, 1914 Giza Camp
Photographer: Mahmud Shadduf*Harvard University-Boston Museum of Fine Arts Expedition*Courtesy Museum of Fine Arts, Boston
"He is considered the father of American Egyptology. As an archaeologist, he was really superb."
"He is considered the father of American Egyptology," said curator Denise Doxey. "As an archaeologist, he was really superb."
Ancient Nubia Now exhibition at the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston. Oct. 13, 2019 to Jan. 20, 2020
* Ann and Graham Gund Gallery
* Photograph © Museum of Fine Arts, Boston
But she says that Reisner based many of his assumptions on history that was written by Egyptians who were at war with Nubians for generations and described Nubians as barbarians. When Reisner came across a beautifully carved, Egyptian stone statue in a tomb in Sudan in 1913, he classified the whole tomb as an Egyptian outpost — even though the statue known as Lady Sennuwy was surrounded by pottery and jewelry that was distinctly Nubian.
"He just couldn't believe that the Nubians did all this themselves," Doxey said. "He was a wonderful archaeologist, but he was not a forward-thinking man on social issues at all. So, he brings his own racial biases, which happened to dovetail nicely with the Egyptians' image of the Nubians. And [it] causes them to completely misinterpret the site."
Reisner didn't believe that the Nubians had conquered southern Egypt for a time, and brought Lady Sennuwy back to Nubia as a prize. But Doxey says that's what actually happened.
"In fact, he had it completely backwards," she said.
Doxey says Reisner contributed to a portrayal of Nubia as a conquered, marginalized culture somehow less important than Egypt, and eventually mostly forgotten by scholars.
Related: Egypt's indigenous Nubians continue their long wait to return to ancestral lands
"It's a vicious cycle because people aren't familiar with Nubia. So, museums are wary about doing exhibitions and [having] nobody come because they don't know what Nubia is," Doxey said. "So, it perpetuates this idea that nobody knows what Nubia is, and it helps to keep that imbalance that Egypt is somehow much more important."
"It's a vicious cycle because people aren't familiar with Nubia. So, museums are wary about doing exhibitions and [having] nobody come because they don't know what Nubia is," Doxey said. "So, it perpetuates this idea that nobody knows what Nubia is, and it helps to keep that imbalance that Egypt is somehow much more important."
But it's been clear for some time that Reisner got it wrong. French and Swiss teams did excavations in Sudan in the 1960s and 1970s and discovered that that tomb Reisner found with the Lady Sennuwy statue was part of a thriving, Nubian metropolis at the center of a trading network that reached far into Africa.
"It's a massive, fortified city with suburbs outside and ports and industrial areas and temples," Doxey said. "So, it was actually a very powerful and important kingdom."
A kingdom that left behind fine pottery that is eggshell thin and dipped in a distinctive translucent blue glaze; and gold jewelry, and sculptures depicting animals such as rams and lions. Items that were ahead of their time, and are possibly evidence of an advanced culture.
That reminds some people of Wakanda, the fictional, ultra-advanced African country in the movie, "Black Panther." Ta-Nehisi Coates, who writes the "Black Panther" series for Marvel, has said he imagines Wakanda being pretty much where Nubia was.
Related: A comic book hero offers a fresh vision of Africa
Ancient Nubia Now exhibition at the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston. October 13, 2019 to January 20, 2020
*Ann and Graham Gund Gallery* Photograph © Museum of Fine Arts, Boston
In a video in the Nubia exhibit, Nicole Aljoe, director of Africana studies at Northeastern University, talks about Pauline Hopkins, an African American writer who, in 1902-1903, wrote a serialized novel, "Of One Blood; Or, The Hidden Self," in which one of the main characters discovers a secret, advanced society of superhumans in the Nubia region.
"It is fascinating — it's this weird kind of proto-science fiction, fantastic, but at the same time supernatural presentation that resonated a lot for me and my students with the film ["Black Panther"] after it came out," Aljoe said. "It'd be really cool if she was prescient in that way."
Related: Why the stakes are so high for the Black Panther
-- Sent from my Linux system.
No comments:
Post a Comment